Different Tire Sizes on the Same Axle
Learn why mixing tire sizes on one axle strains the differential, upsets handling and wears tires unevenly, and how to compare sidewall numbers to fix it.
Contents
- How a diameter difference strains the drivetrain
- Handling and traction changes from unequal tires
- Uneven tire wear from mixed sizes
- Questions about mismatched axle tires
- Is it okay to have different tire sizes on the same axle?
- How can I tell if my tires are different sizes?
- Can mismatched tires damage an all-wheel-drive car?
- What should I do if my axle has two different tire sizes?
Different tire sizes on the same axle make the left and right wheels turn at different speeds. The speed gap strains the differential, upsets handling, and wears the tires unevenly. Even two tires with matching sidewall size numbers can differ in diameter when their brands or tread depths differ. Keeping one size, one model and similar tread depth on each axle removes the mismatch.
How a diameter difference strains the drivetrain
A tire diameter difference across one axle forces the differential to work all the time. The differential lets the left and right wheels turn at different speeds in corners. With unequal tires, its gears keep moving against each other even on a straight road. A limited-slip differential, which locks the wheels together under slip, can overheat and wear its clutches.
Handling and traction changes from unequal tires
Mismatched tires on one axle give the car uneven grip from side to side. A wider tire has a larger contact patch, the area of tread touching the road. Under hard braking or on wet pavement, the car can pull toward the side with more grip. Stability systems and ABS, the anti-lock brakes, may also misread the speed gap as wheel slip.
Uneven tire wear from mixed sizes
Mixed sizes on one axle wear the tires unevenly because each tire carries load differently. The smaller tire turns more often over the same distance and wears faster. Shoulder wear can also appear when the car pulls and you correct with the steering.
Questions about mismatched axle tires
Is it okay to have different tire sizes on the same axle?
No, different tire sizes on the same axle should be avoided except for a temporary spare. The vehicle maker sets one size per axle, and both sides must match. A compact spare is meant only for short, slow trips to a repair shop. Staggered fitment, with wider tires on the rear axle, is a separate case set by the maker.
How can I tell if my tires are different sizes?
You can tell by comparing the size codes molded on each tire sidewall. A code such as 225/45R17 lists width in millimeters, aspect ratio and rim diameter in inches. The aspect ratio is the sidewall height expressed as a share of the width. Check tread depth on both sides too, since a worn tire is smaller than a new one.
Can mismatched tires damage an all-wheel-drive car?
Yes, mismatched tires can damage an all-wheel-drive system, the drivetrain that powers all four wheels. The center differential or coupling must absorb every difference in tire rolling circumference. Some makers set a tight tire diameter tolerance between all four tires for this reason. The allowed gap depends on the vehicle, so check the owner's manual.
What should I do if my axle has two different tire sizes?
The fix for two different tire sizes on an axle is replacing one tire to match the other. Match the size, model and load rating shown on the sidewall. On all-wheel-drive cars, replacing both tires or all four may be required to keep diameters close. A tire technician can measure tread depth and check the wheel and tire pairing.