# Conflicting Tire Size Sources: Which Recommendation to Trust

Learn why tire size recommendations can conflict and how to decide what to trust. Compare the owner's manual, sidewall markings, and the tire placard.

Conflicting tire size sources are resolved by knowing which source carries authority for your vehicle, and the answer is not always the first number you find. This page explains how the owner's manual tire size, the sidewall markings, the tire placard recommendation, and original equipment tire size fit together, and how to settle a conflict between them. 

## Why the sources disagree 

Conflicting tire size recommendations often come from sources written for different model years or trim levels. A manual may cover several versions of a vehicle, while the sidewall shows only the size actually mounted on one wheel. The original equipment tire size printed in a manual section is not a personal recommendation for your exact car. Matching the source to your vehicle's exact build is the step that settles the conflict. 

## Reading the sidewall markings 

The sidewall tire size describes the tire itself, not what the vehicle calls for. Width, aspect ratio, and rim diameter sit there, along with the [load index and speed rating](/articles/tire-load-index-load-range-speed-ratings-material-44528/) as separate figures. A sidewall can show a size that fits the wheel but differs from the factory fitment. The marking tells you what is on the car now, and only that. 

## Using the tire placard 

The tire placard recommendation on the vehicle is tied to one build and lists the size, load index, and speed rating for that build. A placard is an authoritative tire size source because it ships with the car, not with a generic manual. Check that the placard belongs to your vehicle and has not been replaced or covered. When the placard and the manual disagree, the placard for your exact vehicle takes priority. 

## Tire size source questions 

### Which is right when the tire size manual and the sidewall conflict? 

The manual and the sidewall conflict because they answer different questions, so the vehicle-specific source wins. The manual tire size describes what the manufacturer specified, while the sidewall shows what is currently mounted. If the mounted size differs, the tire may be a replacement that departs from the original equipment tire size. Confirm the correct size on the vehicle placard before deciding which to keep. 

### What do I do about conflicting tire size recommendations? 

Conflicting tire size recommendations are settled by ranking the sources for your exact vehicle. Start with the tire placard on the car, then the owner's manual for your model year and trim. Treat a sidewall size as evidence of what is fitted, not as the spec itself. Keep the load index and speed rating consistent with the source you trust. 

### Is the owner's manual tire size always correct? 

The owner's manual tire size is correct for the versions of the vehicle it covers, and it may cover more than one build. A manual can list sizes for several trims, engines, or wheel packages in the same book. The page that matches your exact vehicle is the one to follow. The placard on your car remains the more specific authoritative tire size source. 

### How do I tell which tire size source is authoritative? 

The authoritative tire size source is the one attached to your exact vehicle rather than to a general model line. A placard fixed to the car carries the size, load index, and speed rating for that build. Manuals and websites for a model range are broader and can disagree with each other. For tire size conflict resolution, match every source to your vehicle identification before you compare numbers.
