Acceptable Gage R&R Thresholds
Learn what counts as an acceptable gage R&R result, the 10 and 30 percent limits, and how the number of distinct categories guides a measurement decision.
Contents
Acceptable gage R&R thresholds are the limits used to judge whether a measurement system repeats well enough to trust the readings it produces. A gage R&R study splits variation into repeatability, the spread when one operator measures the same part again, and reproducibility, the spread between operators. The result is often expressed as %GRR, a share of total variation that falls under 10 percent, between 10 and 30 percent, or over 30 percent depending on the decision criteria you apply.
The three bands of %GRR
Acceptance criteria for a gage R&R study sort the %GRR result into three bands. A result under 10 percent of total variation is generally accepted without further review. A result between 10 and 30 percent falls into a conditional zone that may be accepted depending on the part, the cost of error and the customer requirement. A result over 30 percent signals a measurement system that needs improvement before the readings can be trusted.
Repeatability and reproducibility apart
A gage R&R study separates two sources of measurement variation so each can be judged. Repeatability is the variation from one operator measuring the same item with the same instrument. Reproducibility is the variation between different operators using the same instrument on the same item. A high repeatability figure points to the gage or the method, while a high reproducibility figure points to operator technique or training.
Number of distinct categories
The number of distinct categories measures how many separate levels a gage can resolve across the range of parts. A useful gage divides the part variation into several distinct categories, while a gage that cannot separate parts gives a low count. The AIAG guidelines tie this count to the %GRR result, so a value at or below a low threshold supports a decision to improve the measurement system.
Gage R&R acceptance questions
What is an acceptable gage R&R?
An acceptable gage R&R result is one that is under 10 percent of total variation and passes the study without further review. A result between 10 and 30 percent is conditional and depends on the part, the cost of a wrong reading and the requirement of the customer. A result over 30 percent is not acceptable and calls for improving the gage, the method or the operators.
What are the gage R&R study acceptance criteria?
The gage R&R study acceptance criteria rest on the %GRR figure compared with total variation. The three bands are under 10 percent for acceptance, 10 to 30 percent for conditional acceptance and over 30 percent for rejection. The number of distinct categories gives a second check on whether the gage can separate parts.
What does a %GRR over 30 percent mean?
A %GRR over 30 percent means the measurement system contributes too much variation to trust the readings. The gage, the fixture, the method or the operators are likely to need improvement. A result in this band fails the study even when the parts themselves are within tolerance.
How does AIAG set the 10 to 30 percent limits?
The AIAG guidelines set the 10 to 30 percent limits as a three-band decision scheme for measurement systems. The lower limit marks a result that needs no action, and the upper limit marks a result that fails. The middle band is conditional and depends on the risk of a wrong decision.